The trouble at Columbia University is getting worse. The school is dealing with the results of its own investigations. An important teacher has now spoken against the university’s actions. Mahmood Mamdani is a famous professor. He is also the father of New York State Assemblyman Zohran Mamdani. He has criticized the university’s antisemitism task force. He called it a “prosecutorial agency.” He says it is not a group for making peace in the school.
Professor’s Strong Critique at University Senate
At a recent Columbia University Senate meeting, Professor Mahmood Mamdani spoke clearly. He is a respected teacher in the Anthropology Department. His opinion matters to other teachers. Mamdani’s main problem is with the task force’s final report. He says the group moved away from teaching or healing. Instead, it took a punishing position, like a legal prosecution.
Mamdani says this “prosecutorial” way makes people feel watched. It does not create a safe place for talk. The professor’s criticism in New York comes at a hard time. The school is under a lot of pressure from the government and the public. People are watching how it handles protests and student safety. By calling the task force an agency of prosecution, Mamdani says the university cares more about looks and punishment than academic freedom.
Historical Comparison to Colonial Tactics
The most striking part of Mamdani’s criticism was a historical comparison. He compared the university’s plan to the “divide and rule” tactics of the British Empire. Mamdani knows a lot about colonial history. He says the school’s actions today are like old colonial rule. This strategy breaks groups apart to keep control.
In the current Ivy League antisemitism argument in New York City, Mamdani believes the university’s actions might set student groups against each other. He says the task force defines “antisemitism” in a way that targets certain political speech. He argues the school is using the task force as a tool for division. This idea adds deeper thought to the US university antisemitism debate.
Family Connection to New York Politics
This story is bigger because of the Mamdani family’s role in New York City. Mahmood Mamdani is the father of Zohran Mamdani. Zohran is a Democratic Assemblymember for Astoria. Zohran Mamdani has been in the news. He might run for NYC Mayor. News outlets call him an “Anti-Zionist” candidate.
This family link shows how school arguments and city politics mix. The NYC university antisemitism task force findings are not just a school issue. They are part of New York State’s bigger political picture. Professor Mamdani’s school criticism and his son’s political work show how “anti-Zionist” views are growing in New York politics.
ALSO Read: Donald Trump’s Unhinged Latest: Alarming ‘Retribution’ Warning and ‘Hats Off to ICE Shooter’
Context of the Final Report and Academic Response
The task force started after October 7, 2023. It was made to look into reports of antisemitism. But the Columbia University antisemitism report is now very controversial. Some Jewish students and teachers liked the report. They say it shows a bad environment. Others, like Professor Mamdani, see it as an attack on pro-Palestinian speech. The New York Ivy League antisemitism debate has two main sides:
- Keeping Jewish students safe from harassment.
- Keeping teachers and students safe from school overreach and limits on political speech.
The University Senate meeting showed these different views. The teachers are split on what to do next. As the school tries to fix this, the whole country watches Columbia. It is a test case for campus free speech versus antisemitism in the USA.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is Mahmood Mamdani?
He is a famous professor at Columbia University in the Department of Anthropology. He is an important scholar on colonialism and African studies.
What did he call the Columbia task force?
He called it a “prosecutorial agency.” He criticized it for being like an investigation and punishment.
How does this relate to Zohran Mamdani?
Mahmood Mamdani is the father of Zohran Mamdani, a New York State Assemblyman.
What are “divide and rule” tactics?
It is a political plan to keep power. You break larger groups into smaller pieces. The smaller pieces have less power than the person or group in charge.
Disclaimer
The news information presented here is based on available reports and reliable sources. Readers should cross-check updates from official news outlets.