By [Sadam khan yousaf zai ], Staff Writer
In a notable turn of events in the prominent sexual misconduct investigation involving Eastern Cape Judge President Selby Mbenenge, his defense team has decisively dismissed claims that he transmitted sexually explicit content to his accuser. The attorneys maintain that no such material exists, branding the accusations as unsubstantiated and underscoring the necessity for procedural fairness and judicial integrity.
Timeline of Allegations: How the Case Emerged:
The matter dates back to December 2022, when Andiswa Mengo, a Clerical Officer at the Makhanda High Court, Formally reported Allegations of Sexual misconduct Against Mbenenge. She Contended that he Sent her Inappropriate Communications and Graphic media THROUGH WhatsApp.
These claims triggered a formal judicial tribunal in early 2025, where officials began assessing the validity of the alleged digital content, with particular focus on the image evidence.
Outlets such as Wikipedia, GroundUp News, and the Daily Dispatch have covered the story extensively, indicating its national relevance and considerable public engagement.
Defense’s Argument: “No Graphic Content Was Sent:
Judge Mbenenge’s legal counsel has categorically denied the existence of any indecent or inappropriate imagery being distributed by their client. They argue that the claims lack supporting evidence and are without legal foundation.
“There is no reliable data—digital or forensic—that affirms the presence of such images,” the legal team asserted during tribunal proceedings.
The defense further warned of the reputational consequences associated with the dissemination of unverified claims, stressing that all allegations must be addressed through established legal channels.
Public Sentiment and Media Coverage:
This case has received broad media exposure, particularly from publications concerned with judicial accountability and ethical governance in South Africa.
Public sentiment remains split. While Some individuals Advocate for Transparency and Justice, others emphasize the Importance of Avoiding premature Conclusions, citing the fundamental legal principle of innocence until proven guilty.
Summary Points:
- The Allegation: Judge Selby Mbenenge stands accused of sending suggestive messages and explicit photos to a subordinate via WhatsApp.
- Defense Standpoint: His attorneys argue that the claims are speculative and lack credible digital proof.
- Wider Impact: The case has prompted national discussion on professional conduct, judicial due process, and the public trust in South Africa’s legal institutions.